Defining Itihāsa: Correcting Common Mischaracterizations

Image
Abhimanyu Vadh (The Slaying of Abhimanyu) — Painting From Mahabharat by Nandalal Bose. NOTE TO READER: All references are provided through hotlinks identifiable by underlined words and phrases in the main body of the text. The hotlink opens the relevant page of the citation. There is a peculiar violence in translation. When a word from one civilization is dropped into the vocabulary of another, it rarely arrives unaccompanied — it drags the assumptions of its new home along with it, and those assumptions quietly begin to govern how the word is read. Along with many other indic terms, this is what happened to itihāsa ( इतिहास ). Translated as “ history ,” it was made to answer to the standards of Ranke and the archive . Translated as “ myth ” or “ mythology ,” it was made to answer to Frazer and the comparative anthropologist ’s suspicion of any claim to divine agency in a factual narrative. Neither translation was chosen by the tradition itself. Both were imposed on it, in the sam...

NAVARĀTRI: Nine Nights of Purification


Navarātri is here. For nine nights, devotees recite the Devī Māhātmya, also called the Durgā Saptaśatī or Caṇḍī Pāṭha. It has 700 verses in 13 chapters, set within the Mārkaṇḍeya Purāṇa. Over these nights I want to read it slowly, one asura at a time, and ask what each battle asks of the person reciting.

The Goddess Ambika leading the mother Goddesses in battle against the demon Raktabija, folio from a Devimahatmya; Kathmandu Valley, Nepal; c. 1725–1750; Opaque watercolour and ink on paper; 11.4 x 20.3 cm. Los Angeles County Museum of Art, California

Two things need to be kept apart. One is what the text says. The other is the meditative reading that tradition has built on it, in which each asura is an inner obstacle — consistent with the upanishadic explanation of devās. The text itself has no days. Its 13 chapters tell three separate episodes, and the Goddess’s battles are not one continuous campaign. The nine-night scheme here is a devotional arrangement laid over the text, and recitation schedules vary by lineage and household. On a few days it does not follow the order of the chapters, and I will say so where that happens.

The nine forms of Durgā honored on these nights are not named in the 13 chapters of the Devī Māhātmya. They are listed in the Devī Kavaca, a separate protective hymn spoken by Brahmā to Mārkaṇḍeya, which is traditionally recited before the Saptaśatī (verses 3 to 5 of the Kavaca itself).

प्रथमं शैलपुत्री च द्वितीयं ब्रह्मचारिणी ।
तृतीयं चन्द्रघण्टेति कूष्माण्डेति चतुर्थकम् ॥ 3 ॥

पञ्चमं स्कन्दमातेति षष्ठं कात्यायनीति च ।
सप्तमं कालरात्रीति महागौरीति चाष्टमम् ॥ 4 ॥

नवमं सिद्धिदात्री च नवदुर्गाः प्रकीर्तिताः ।
उक्तान्येतानि नामानि ब्रह्मणैव महात्मना ॥ 5 ॥

I could not find it among the Mārkaṇḍeya Purāṇa’s own chapters, and its textual origin is uncertain. The Kavaca gives only the names, in order: Śailaputrī, Brahmacāriṇī, Candraghaṇṭā, Kūṣmāṇḍā, Skandamātā, Kātyāyanī, Kālarātrī, Mahāgaurī, and Siddhidātrī. Pairing each form with a particular asura, as I do below, is a later devotional and meditative reading and not something the text states.

The Beginning

The first chapter does not begin with a battle. It begins with a man who has lost everything.

King Suratha has been driven from his kingdom by enemies and betrayed by his own ministers. He wanders into a forest and reaches the hermitage of the sage Medhas. There he meets a merchant, Samādhi, who has been thrown out by his wife and sons. Both men have been wronged, and both are still emotionally tied to the people who wronged them. Suratha worries about the kingdom he can no longer protect. Samādhi worries about children who have rejected him. Neither understands why his mind will not let go.

They ask Medhas. His answer (DM 1.55) is the doctrine of the whole text, and he states it before any asura appears:

ज्ञानिनामपि चेतांसि देवी भगवती हि सा ।
बलादाकृष्य मोहाय महामाया प्रयच्छति ॥

jñānināmapi cetāṃsi devī bhagavatī hi sā |
balādākṛṣya mohāya mahāmāyā prayacchati ||


“She is the Bhagavatī Devī. Even the minds of the wise she seizes by force and gives over to delusion. She is Mahāmāyā.”

The next verse completes the thought:

तया विसृज्यते विश्वं जगदेतच्चराचरम् ।
सैषा प्रसन्ना वरदा नृणां भवति मुक्तये ॥

tayā visṛjyate viśvaṃ jagadetaccarācaram |
saiṣā prasannā varadā nṛṇāṃ bhavati muktaye ||


“By her this world, moving and unmoving, is brought forth. When she is gracious, she grants boons and becomes the cause of release.”

The same power that binds also frees. Everything in the chapters that follow depends on this.

When she roars with laughter, the worlds shake, and Mahiṣāsura rushes toward the sound

“When she roars with laughter, the worlds shake, and Mahiṣāsura rushes toward the sound”

In chapter 2, the Goddess is born from the gods’ defeat. After a war of a hundred years, Mahiṣāsura has taken Indra’s seat and the offices of the Sun, Fire, Wind, the Moon, Yama, and Varuṇa, and the gods wander the earth like mortals. With Brahmā at their head, they go to Viṣṇu and Śiva and lay out what has happened. Hearing it, Viṣṇu and Śiva grow angry, great radiance (tejas) issues from Viṣṇu, from Brahmā, and from Śiva, and then from the bodies of Indra and the other gods, and all of it gathers into one mass like a blazing mountain. That radiance becomes a woman (nārī) whose brilliance fills the three worlds. The text then assigns her body to the gods. Śiva’s radiance becomes her face, Yama’s her hair, Soma’s her breasts, Indra’s her waist, Varuṇa’s her legs and thighs, the Earth’s her hips, Brahmā’s her feet, the Sun’s her toes, the Vasus’ her fingers, Kubera’s her nose, Prajāpati’s her teeth, Fire’s her three eyes, the twilights’ her brows, and the Wind’s her ears. Then each god arms her from his own store. Śiva draws a trident from his trident, Viṣṇu a discus from his discus, and Indra a thunderbolt from his thunderbolt. She is not a rescuer sent from outside. She is the gods’ own scattered powers, real but not enough on their own, gathered into one. When she roars with laughter, the worlds shake, and Mahiṣāsura rushes toward the sound.

Day 1: Madhu and Kaiṭabha

Navadurgā: Śailaputrī | Chapter 1 | Inertia and restless passion

At the end of a cosmic cycle, Viṣṇu sleeps on the waters in yoganidrā. Two asuras, Madhu and Kaiṭabha, arise from the wax of his ear (viṣṇukarṇamalodbhūtau) and move to kill Brahmā. Brahmā cannot fight them, so he praises the Goddess who holds Viṣṇu in sleep and asks her to release him. She withdraws, Viṣṇu wakes, and he fights for five thousand years without winning. Then Mahāmāyā deludes the asuras themselves. Proud of their strength, they offer Viṣṇu a boon, and he asks for their deaths.

The meditative reading takes the pair as tamas and rajas: dull inertia and restless drive. They are not invaders. They are residue produced by the body of awareness itself, and they appear when attention sleeps. Śailaputrī, “daughter of the mountain,” is the steady ground from which the work begins.

Day 2: Mahiṣāsura

Navadurgā: Brahmacāriṇī | Chapters 2 and 3 | Arrogance and intoxication with power

Mahiṣa’s army is cut down by the Goddess and her lion, and the great asura himself enters in his buffalo form, terrorizing her gaṇas. She binds him with a noose. He sheds the buffalo form and becomes a lion, then a man with a sword, then an elephant, then a buffalo again. The Goddess drinks, laughs, and tells him to roar for a moment while she drinks. Then she leaps onto him, presses him down with her foot, and strikes him in the neck with her spear. He is half-emerged from his own mouth when she cuts off his head with her sword.

Here the asura is arrogance joined to dull animality, the self that drinks on its own power. The shape-shifting is the ego rewriting its identity every time it is cornered. Brahmacāriṇī, the Goddess in her aspect of austerity, is the first answer to this: discipline before confrontation.

Author’s sketch of the nine days of Navarātri

Vairagya (detachment) through 9 days of fasting, dhumra-alochna (clouded thinking) gets vanquished, Madhu & Kaitabha (addiction & avarice) get overpowered, Chanda Munda, Shumbha Nishumbha all start getting weaker. The shakti rises! (Author’s sketch)

Day 3: Dhūmralocana

Navadurgā: Candraghaṇṭā | Chapter 6 | Clouded vision and delusion

Śumbha, enraged that Devī has refused him, sends the general Dhūmralocana, “smoky-eyed,” to drag her to the court. She does not use a weapon. At her sound of hūṃ he is reduced to ash.

The name says it all: vision clouded by smoke. This obstacle is not fought with effort. It is dissolved by the right sound at the right moment. Candraghaṇṭā, the one with the bell, carries that sound.

Day 4: Cikṣura

Navadurgā: Kūṣmāṇḍā | Chapter 3 | Sense-pleasure and deceptive sweetness

Cikṣura is Mahiṣa’s commander, and when he sees his army being slaughtered he goes out in anger against Ambikā. He showers her with arrows. She cuts them down as if in play, then destroys his horses, his charioteer, his bow, and his banner. He rushes at her on foot with sword and shield, then hurls a blazing trident. She releases her own trident, which shatters his and strikes him down.

In this reading, his weapons are the attachments that look attractive: pleasures that bind exactly because they are sweet. Tradition calls Kūṣmāṇḍā the creator of the universe with a gentle smile. A smile that creates a world also has the strength to see through its charms.

Day 5: Caṇḍa and Muṇḍa

Navadurgā: Skandamātā | Chapter 7 | Anger and possessiveness

When Caṇḍa and Muṇḍa approach with their army, the Goddess’s anger darkens her face, and Kālī springs from her brow. Kālī seizes both asuras and presents their heads to Ambikā, who says:

यस्माच्चण्डं च मुण्डं च गृहीत्वा त्वमुपागता । चामुण्डेति ततो लोके ख्याता देवी भविष्यसि ॥ ७.२७

yasmāc caṇḍaṃ ca muṇḍaṃ ca gṛhītvā tvam upāgatā | cāmuṇḍeti tato loke khyātā devī bhaviṣyasi ||

“Since you have come bringing Caṇḍa and Muṇḍa, you will be known in the world as Cāmuṇḍā.”

I read Caṇḍa as anger and Muṇḍa as greed or possessiveness. The Goddess earns her name by seizing them. Skandamātā, the mother of Skanda, shows that the force that overcomes them is nurturing, not cold.

Day 6: Raktabīja

Navadurgā: Kātyāyanī | Chapter 8 | Endless proliferating desire

Raktabīja means “blood-seed.” Every drop of his blood that touches the ground becomes another Raktabīja, so each wound multiplies the army. The Goddess cannot win by cutting. She calls Kālī to open her mouth wide and drink the blood before it falls. Then she strikes him, and he is finished.

This is the clearest teaching of the nine days. Desire feeds on its own satisfaction, and fighting each copy only makes more of them. The answer is to deny the seed the ground. Kātyāyanī, the warrior form, is the force that does this without hesitation.

Day 7: Niśumbha

Navadurgā: Kālarātrī | Chapter 9 | Pride — unbridled ambition & false superiority

Niśumbha is Śumbha’s younger brother, and he leads the final assault. He falls to the Goddess’s weapons. The text then says another figure emerges from his body, and Devī beheads that one too.

His ambition outlasts its own death for a moment, which is how pride behaves. Pride & Ego are brothers. The younger brother Ni-Shumbha (intense-slaughter) represents the attachment and “mine-ness” (mamakara) that always accompanies pride. Unchecked pride and attachment “slaughter” or destroy inner peace, spiritual progress, relationship with others and clarity of mind. “Mine-ness” can be so intense, it can seem to momentarily outlast death too —Devi has to kill him twice! Kālarātrī, “the dark night,” is the form that meets it where it hides, in the shadow that grasping casts on the self.

Day 8: Śumbha

Navadurgā: Mahāgaurī | Chapter 10 | The root ego and duality

Śumbha is left alone. He accuses the Goddess of fighting on the strength of others, because the Śaktis of the gods stand beside her. She answers:

एकैवाहं जगत्यत्र द्वितीया का ममापरा । पश्यैता दुष्ट मय्येव विशन्त्यो मद्विभूतयः ॥ १०.५

ekaivāhaṃ jagatyatra dvitīyā kā mamāparā | paśyaitā duṣṭa mayyeva viśantyo madvibhūtayaḥ ||

“I alone exist here in the world. Who else is there besides me? See, O wicked one, these are my own manifestations entering into me.”

The other goddesses merge into her, and the last battle begins. Śumbha is the root ego, the claim of separateness that every other obstacle rests on. Then duality is shown to be one power appearing as many, the claim has nothing left to stand on. Mahāgaurī, the radiant, is the color of a mind rinsed clean.

Day 9: Siddhidātrī

Navadurgā: Siddhidātrī | Chapter 11 | Liberation and inner peace

No asura dies tonight. The gods approach the Goddess with their praise, and the great hymn to Nārāyaṇī begins:

सर्वमङ्गलमाङ्गल्ये शिवे सर्वार्थसाधिके । शरण्ये त्र्यम्बके गौरि नारायणि नमोऽस्तु ते ॥ ११.१०

sarvamaṅgalamāṅgalye śive sarvārthasādhike | śaraṇye tryambake gauri nārāyaṇi namo’stu te ||

“O auspiciousness of all that is auspicious, O Śivā, accomplisher of every aim, O refuge, three-eyed Gaurī, Nārāyaṇī, I bow to you.”

Siddhidātrī, giver of accomplishment, stands for what is left when the work is done: stillness, fullness, and peace. Vijayadashami follows.

Closing

Read together, the nine nights trace a path. Tamas and rajas come first, then the sharper obstacles of pride, anger, and desire, then the ego at the root, and finally rest. Suratha and Samādhi began by asking why they could not let go. The answer is spread across these nights.

A note on fasting

Many who recite the Devī Māhātmya these nine nights also fast. The text itself does not prescribe a fast. The observance comes from the later vrata literature, and its form varies by household: one meal a day, fruit and milk, or a full upavāsa. The word is worth a look. Upavāsa means “dwelling near” (upa + vas), and the intent is to dwell near the divine by setting appetite aside.

The logic follows from the obstacles above. Madhu and Kaiṭabha are the tamas of heaviness and the rajas of restlessness, and the Gītā links both to what we eat: stale, dulling food is tāmasa, and pungent, exciting food is rājasa (17.9–10). The Chāndogya Upaniṣad states the principle in a single line:

आहारशुद्धौ सत्त्वशुद्धिः सत्त्वशुद्धौ ध्रुवा स्मृतिः । स्मृतिलम्भे सर्वग्रन्थीनां विप्रमोक्षः ॥ ७.२६.२

āhāraśuddhau sattvaśuddhiḥ sattvaśuddhau dhruvā smṛtiḥ | smṛtilambhe sarvagranthīnāṃ vipramokṣaḥ ||

“When intake is pure, the mind is purified. When the mind is purified, memory is firm. When memory is gained, all the knots are loosened.”

Those knots are what held Suratha and Samādhi. A fast is also a daily rehearsal of the Raktabīja lesson: desire grows when every craving is met, and the fast declines to feed the seed.

विषया विनिवर्तन्ते निराहारस्य देहिन: ।
रसवर्जं रसोऽप्यस्य परं दृष्ट्वा निवर्तते ॥ 59॥

viṣhayā vinivartante nirāhārasya dehinaḥ
rasa-varjaṁ raso ’pyasya paraṁ dṛiṣhṭvā nivartate

The Gītā (2.59) adds an honest caution. Abstaining turns the objects of the senses away, but the taste for them remains until something higher is seen. The fast supports the work, and the Goddess’s grace completes it. Tradition also asks that the fast suit the body, adjusted to age and health, so that it clears the mind and does not punish the person.

The nine-night observance itself comes from the Purāṇic literature, not from the Māhātmya. In the Devī Bhāgavata Purāṇa (3.30.18 to 20), the sage Nārada advises Rāma to worship the Goddess for nine nights in order to recover Sītā, and the text praises fasting, silent repetition of the mantra, and the homa ceremony as part of that worship. The emphasis on night echoes the Vedic Rātri Sūkta (Ṛgveda 10.127). So the fast and the nine nights are linked in the tradition.

A Closing Word from the Devī

The Devī Māhātmya does not end with a battle. Its last chapter is the Devī’s own speech, in which she says what the recitation is for. She begins:

एभिः स्तवैश्च मां नित्यं स्तोष्यते यः समाहितः । तस्याहं सकलां बाधां नाशयिष्याम्यसंशयम् ॥ १२.१

ebhiḥ stavaiś ca māṃ nityaṃ stoṣyate yaḥ samāhitaḥ | tasyāhaṃ sakalāṃ bādhāṃ nāśayiṣyāmy asaṃśayam ||

“Whoever, with a collected mind, praises me constantly with these hymns, I will destroy every one of his obstacles, without doubt.”

Everything turns on one word, samāhita, “collected.” The promise is made to the one whose mind is gathered, not to the one who simply recites. She then names what is to be recited: the destruction of Madhu and Kaiṭabha, the slaying of Mahiṣāsura, and the death of Śumbha and Niśumbha, the very episodes these nine nights have followed. She asks for it on the eighth, ninth and fourteenth lunar days, with a focussed mind. In the usual count, the eighth and ninth fall on the last two nights of Navaratri.

The text asks for reciting and hearing, with devotion and a gathered mind. It does not ask for a fast, which belongs to the later vrata tradition. In verse 12 the result is credited to her grace (matprasādena), not to the effort. If the nine nights have been a slow reading of what binds the mind, this is the instruction left for the reader: gather the mind, stay with her account to the end, and let the rest be her grace.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Art of Rama's Pattabhishekham (Rajyabhisheka)

Śikṣā: Phonetics of the Gods

Sita's Agni Pariksha